Is it cheaper to turn down the heat when you leave home or keep it at the same temperature all day?
This question sparked a debate in my household over the weekend. I argued that turning down the heat saves money (my father’s voice echoing in my mind.) My other half insisted that warming the house back up after dropping the temperature uses more energy than you save.
Never one to shy away from a debate, I decided to get to the bottom of it. The short answer is: it depends.
Let’s take a look at what the best information from Natural Resources Canada tells us so I can maybe save you a debate of your own – and possibly save you some money on your energy bills too.
If you have electric baseboard heaters or a conventional furnace
Turning down the temperature when you’re sleeping or away for several hours can save energy. According to Natural Resources Canada, lowering your thermostat by just 1°C for eight hours can reduce heating energy use by about 2%.
Try lowering the temperature a few degrees before bed or when you’re out for the day. Your heating system will use energy to warm things back up, but that doesn’t usually cancel out the savings from keeping your home cooler while you’re away or asleep.
If you have a heat pump
The advice is a little different in this case. Heat pumps work efficiently when maintaining a fairly steady temperature. Turning the heat way down can mean your system has to work harder to warm your home again.
Natural Resources Canada recommends limiting temperature changes to 2°C or less. However, some companies have started selling heat pumps with compatible smart thermostats that can manage larger temperature changes efficiently, so smaller temperature setbacks may still save energy.
If you’re unsure what kind of system you have, check your heat pump’s recommendations and avoid big temperature swings unless you know if your system is designed to handle them.
What if you have both?
This is actually the case in my home. We have a heat pump on the main floor and electric baseboard heaters throughout the house.
If your home has both too, Natural Resources Canada recommends setting baseboard thermostats about 2–3°C lower than your heat pump’s temperature in areas heated by both systems. This helps your more efficient heat pump do most of the work without the baseboards kicking in unnecessarily.
In rooms where the baseboards are the only source of heat, turning down the temperature when you’re sleeping or away for several hours can still help save energy.
The verdict
Turning down the heat can save money, but how much depends on your heating system and thermostat. So both sides of our household debate had a point.


Bailey’s one-pot cheesy pumpkin pasta